|
FIELD MANUAL OF ENGLISH CLICHÉS
(BEING THE ESSENTIAL GUIDE FOR ALL WORD-WATCHERS)
All but the mute among us are word-twitchers
rushing to record in grubby exercise books
any hackneyed phrase that happens to fly
our way. Yet, unlike the ornithological,
the ordinary-logical enthusiasts collect
the least exotic, the most hackneyed phrases
on the wing.
It must not be supposed, though, that any
modicum of agreement subsists among them
as to what constitutes a cliché. What, if
anything, is there to distinguish it from
an expression that is simply an idiom? -
just as frequently used, but without the
power to kill by boredom.
The word itself derives incidentally from
the process of the stereotype: as the late
eighteenth century matrix fell on the molten
metal, its French inventors thought they
heard it say cleash, so they named the resulting
embossed plates clichés. By association,
any mechanical reproduction came to be known
as such.
So much for history, however, to whose voice
we listen at our peril, missing the point
about the past - that it is over and done
with - and becoming second-rate copycats.
If we do not mean our thinking to be cloned
in this mechanistic sense, we should turn
our attention to what the word means after
being around for some two hundred years.
Take the following phrases: at the end of the day, in the fullness of
time, ultimately, in due course, in the long
run, by and by, sooner or later, in the final
analysis and when all is said and done. They all mean much the same thing, but are
they all clichés? Certainly not. And the
ones that aren't - in due course, in the long run, sooner or later and by and by - say it just as repetitiously, yet at the
same time more honestly and straightforwardly.
The clichés worth collecting are slightly
pretentious, smug and self-satisfied, in
short, given to regarding themselves furtively
in the mirror.
Hold on a minute! Webster's tells us that
a cliché is 'a trite phrase or expression'
and 'trite' it defines as 'lacking the freshness
that evokes attention or interest'. In the long run would in that case qualify. And yet are
dictionaries oracular? In this case I think
not. If they were, any phrase that's been
used a few billion times would be a cliché,
and this would include at length and even the word eventually. That would be such a reductio ad absurdum
that man, coat and cheese would also be included - indeed, almost
the entire English language, apart from such
hidden treasures as dithyrambic.
The bottom line is this: a cliché in the
mouth is worth ten in the dictionary. At
the end of the day we must stand up and be
counted, putting our money where our mouth
is. If our platform is the deterrent effect
of verbal chain reactions, we must not raise
the spectre of reciprocal annihilation. To
do so would be to open the floodgates of
war, and that is the very time we need to
raise our nuclear umbrellas.
Clichés often set out with good intentions.
Ariel sang:
Nothing of him that doth fade
But doth suffer a sea change
Into something rich and strange.
and that was fair enough, but every political
hack that mimics this fairy adds a dull weight
to the phrase till even when we meet it in
Shakespeare we are bound to shudder.
Equally, the first man, woman or child to
say 'in this day and age' used a rather sugared
rhetoric but one without the self-important
emphasis the phrase has accrued. And during
the development of any cliché, those who
become offended by its clowning mannerism
undergo a spectrum of emotions from reluctant
admiration through resentment to a kind of
bitter laughter.
Only when laughter is directed at this shadow-language
can it be frankly comical, as when we read
in Geoffrey Taylor's 'Cruel, Clever Cat':
Sally, having swallowed cheese,
Directs down holes the scented breeze
Enticing thus with baited breath
Nice mice to an untimely death.
Yet there is final spectral revulsion when
clichés are used in all seriousness.
So forget about dictionaries. In common sense
we know something must have been left out
of the definition. And it is what I have
called the cliché's pretentiousness. The
voice takes on a Churchillian timbre, the
lower lip pouts, and we put a proud boot
on the flank of the words we've slaughtered.
As we say 'at the end of the day' - again
and yet again -, the lip may simply twitch,
the pitch descend a mere semitone (even pomposity
can become a habit), but these shifts are
there - if only subliminally. This is what
it comes down to when all is said and done.
|